ISS judges
4 posters
Page 1 of 1
ISS judges
what is ur opinion on judges?is their judgement biased or is it fair enough on all the contestants?
madhumusic- Number of posts : 13
Age : 105
Location : UK
Registration date : 2007-12-27
Re: ISS judges
Definitely not fare enough on all the contestants I feel/ am sure they are giving more marks to some of them !!
number 1: Najim gets more marks than he deserves .. i felt that many times!! i agree that he sings very well... but still some times they give more marks to him..for Ilayaraja hits song, he got 87!!!! even though it was not that great singing..
number2: our so called great singer Vani .. always she gets very high marks than she really deserved ..she is very clever and acts like a humble person ..
number3: Vijay no comments to say ...i like his way of singing with good feel, etc... but his voice is
number4: Hesham .. he sang few tamil songs with lot of problems and he doesnt have good voice clarity .. still judges feels he sings good
Now, ppl who gets less marks
Number 1: Thushar .. i dont think he ever got the deserved marks so far in this competition he is really a good singer with lot of good qualities like voice, feel, sangathis etc... for semi classical song, they gave him just 83!!! for that tough song
Number 2: Durga
Number3 : Teenu...always they gave her less marks even though she sings better than Vani
Number4: Bineetha.. she sings with lot of feel and she has good voice too...judges always gave her less marks
thats it for now from me ...
number 1: Najim gets more marks than he deserves .. i felt that many times!! i agree that he sings very well... but still some times they give more marks to him..for Ilayaraja hits song, he got 87!!!! even though it was not that great singing..
number2: our so called great singer Vani .. always she gets very high marks than she really deserved ..she is very clever and acts like a humble person ..
number3: Vijay no comments to say ...i like his way of singing with good feel, etc... but his voice is
number4: Hesham .. he sang few tamil songs with lot of problems and he doesnt have good voice clarity .. still judges feels he sings good
Now, ppl who gets less marks
Number 1: Thushar .. i dont think he ever got the deserved marks so far in this competition he is really a good singer with lot of good qualities like voice, feel, sangathis etc... for semi classical song, they gave him just 83!!! for that tough song
Number 2: Durga
Number3 : Teenu...always they gave her less marks even though she sings better than Vani
Number4: Bineetha.. she sings with lot of feel and she has good voice too...judges always gave her less marks
thats it for now from me ...
su1234- Number of posts : 8
Age : 44
Location : USA
Registration date : 2008-01-09
Re: ISS judges
In my openion Thushar is really a great singer..Ofcourse he deserves more marks than Najim in previous round. I don't think judges are biased...they are very experienced and also proved . So their comments are very valuable.
oops- Number of posts : 3
Age : 48
Location : IN
Registration date : 2008-01-11
Re: ISS judges
my first vote would go for DURGA - she never got the marks she deserved.
n then THUSHAR - same story with him too.
i feel VANI always got more marks even though she made mistakes.
and of course, the recent episdoe is AMRUTHA - Ilaiyaraja hits round. had it been any other contestant, judges would have given only 65. But she got 81.
n then THUSHAR - same story with him too.
i feel VANI always got more marks even though she made mistakes.
and of course, the recent episdoe is AMRUTHA - Ilaiyaraja hits round. had it been any other contestant, judges would have given only 65. But she got 81.
toil56- Number of posts : 15
Age : 51
Location : USA
Registration date : 2007-12-26
Re: ISS judges
my first vote would go for DURGA - she never got the marks she deserved.
n then THUSHAR - same story with him too.
i feel VANI always got more marks even though she made mistakes.
and of course, the recent episdoe is AMRUTHA - Ilaiyaraja hits round. had it been any other contestant, judges would have given only 65. But she got 81.
n then THUSHAR - same story with him too.
i feel VANI always got more marks even though she made mistakes.
and of course, the recent episdoe is AMRUTHA - Ilaiyaraja hits round. had it been any other contestant, judges would have given only 65. But she got 81.
toil56- Number of posts : 15
Age : 51
Location : USA
Registration date : 2007-12-26
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|